Today was the very last final crit on the BA (hons) Graphic Design course! Scary!
We had to take along all the briefs and the development work that we've produced since January for the Final Major Project (FMP).
So for me that was
1. Stuff-O-Meter
2. Salvedge Identity
3. Cooki Identity
4. Confections
The Stuff-O-Meter and Salvedge Identity briefs are as complete as possible, but I'm still waiting to find out if Salvedge stationary has been printed at YPS printing on the correct paper stock...
The Cooki Identity is complete, but the only concern I've had is the construction of the CD case I've tried producing. The sticker on the front of the case looks crap, and I brought up in the crit about how I might go about doing it, maybe altering my original designs.
The feedback from the group was...
- in the development work it doesn't appear that I've put much thought into the designs for the CD case, not trying things out and just generally rushing it. I know it was a quick decision I made, but I feel I did consider a few different design ideas. So this is something I should maybe look at.
- Also, instead of the sticker on the front cover, as the case front would be transparent, nothing to obscure the actual CD on the inside, to maybe consider just producing a design to go on the CD itself.
- Overall, I've not to spend much time resolving this. Maybe spend just half a day on resolving this final problem. Get it finished and move on!
The main focus for this crit, I wanted to be on the confections brief. The latest and the one that's still got a way to go. I'm pleased with my progress so far, producing an identity I wanted to go with, looking at design variations for a business card, letterhead, compliment slip, carrier bags, the smaller sweets bags, the labels for the sweets jars, a web layout and some packaging ideas.
i just needed to know I'm heading in the right direction and if what I'm doing is correct and that I'm not missing anything out.
Shown below are some of the label and packaging ideas that I took along to the crit...
For this brief I asked specific questions I wanted feedback for. These were the questions and the feedback I received..
1. Do you think the colours I'm working with are appropriate? The purple on grey for general stuff, and then the ranges for the packaging?
- The designs do look nice, but I don't think that grey is the most appropriate choice of colour. Maybe a colour found in sweets, or white/off white?
- You could maybe lighten the grey a little? Love the sweet case, looks really good. The text on the sweet jar labels looks a bit lost and are hard to read though.
2. I've provided a sheet with the other things I intend to create for this project. Are they all appropriate? Is there anything I'm missing?
- Everything is appropriate. Could include a design invoice?
A chocolate stamp with the logo on it?!
- Bags, brown/off white. Screenprint/digital if flat. Context show/photo in a shop. Till / Wallpaper / Dispenser / Box for cards.
3. I think I'm happy with the direction I'm heading in. But do you have any tips? Anything you think I need to consider? Or am I going completely in the wrong direction?!?!
- Direction is spot on, great concept/idea and identity. Now just highly produce stocks, swatches and look at different printing methods.
- Think about photography, presentation - what goes with what? In groups? Labels? Website maybe separately presented?
Then the general feedback discussed by the group was..
- Brightness of colours used? Try out different colours and stocks.
- Variations/investigation of logo. More detail, more to it. It's a bit too simple and straight forward at the moment.
-Investigation into different style, logo, format, colour.
- But overall it is really good :)
Another point that was brought up was the submission boards for the Stuff-O-Meter. As many in the group saw me progress with this brief, they saw the timeline/illustration of the life time resources of the hairdryer (shown below)
It was brought up that it was no where to be seen on any of my final submission boards. My reasoning for that is because during one of the crits for that brief, this idea was pretty much laughed at :s Even though I was advised to not go along with it, I still did. But at these final stages was unsure what to actually do with it, but now I've decided I'm going to some how incorporate it into my other work for submission. So that needs looking at again.
Overall, I'm pleased with the feedback from the final crit. I have a good idea what I still need to do, which is still quite a lot! So watch this space for a time plan from now until a week and 2 days away (the deadline!!!).